expert advice MORE
Perfectionist Daughter, Frazzled Mother
Q: My six-year-old has a very active imagination and remembers everything that is taught to her. Orally, she does just fine, but when it comes to taking pencil in hand, she just cries and cries. She wants all her letters and numbers to look perfect. I have tried to make her understand that these things take time, and have tried the, "I understand, here is an eraser, let's fix it and try again" method. I have even made dots to form the letter and had her trace it. When she goes out of the line, she gets even more upset. Help!
A: We can't be certain how this perfectionistic behavior started in your daughter. Maybe she was praised too much for getting things "exactly right" or perhaps the quality of her written work is compared and shown publicly in the classroom. Or maybe she is just "wired" that way!
Here are some suggestions: Family members should laughingly point out their own mistakes and good-naturedly go on from there. For example: "I can't believe I turned left at that street instead of right. Now how can I fix this!?" Do not give her a lot of sympathy when she cries over her writing. That just reinforces it. Be matter-of-fact and less consoling. I know this is hard to do, but she's letting her emotions get out of control at this point so you have to keep tabs on yours.
If she is truly having some problems forming her letters or writes too slowly to keep up with her speedy brain, teach her the "speedwriting" game. Have her pick a few sentences from her favorite book, then copy them down as fast as she can while you time her. Neatness doesn't count. The idea is to beat your own time. Use the same passage once a day for three to four days and then get another one. If she improves her time, then she gets a little reward (like more computer time). Explain that this silly but fun game will make her writing hand a little stronger by exercising it. It can often help to loosen up the pencil grip while strengthening the hand overall. I would also de-emphasize perfection in general with her. Mention this to her teacher as well so that she can do the same.
More on: Expert Advice
Noreen Joslyn is a licensed independent social worker in the state of Ohio and is a member of the Academy of Certified Social Workers. She has a master's degree in Social Work, specializing in family and children, from the University of Pittsburgh. She is a psychiatric social worker in private practice with Ken DeLuca, Ph.D. & Associates, where she counsels parents and children.